Integration of Puccinia punctiformis into organic management of Cirsium arvense

Abstract

Cirsium arvense is a perennial weed that causes significant economic losses in agriculture. An extensive rhizomatous root system makes C. arvense difficult to manage, particularly in organic cropping systems that use tillage as a primary management tool. To improve organic management of C. arvense, there is a need for the development of alternative and integrated weed management toolsets that include C. arvense biological controls. Puccinia punctiformis is a fungal pathogen that systemically infects C. arvense, with the potential to reduce host vigor. The goal of this research was to assess the impacts of P. punctiformis within organic cropping systems, using a greenhouse and a field study that examined integration of the biocontrol with cultural and mechanical management tools. In the greenhouse, P. punctiformis was integrated with a competitive annual cropping sequence, where C. arvense's biomass production and competitive ability was assessed. Cirsium arvense biomass production was significantly reduced when P. punctiformis was integrated with the cultural management tactic, more than individual use of the biocontrol or cultural management alone. Additionally, P. punctiformis reduced the competitive ability of C. arvense over time. In the field, P. punctiformis was integrated with mechanical management, where reduced and standard tillage treatments were evaluated to determine the effects on P. punctiformis and C. arvense abundance. The reduced tillage treatment caused a greater increase in P. punctiformis infected C. arvense stems compared to standard tillage, however there was no impact to asymptomatic C. arvense stem density from either tillage treatment. In both tillage treatments, there was a reduction in asymptomatic C. arvense stem density in samples where P. punctiformis infection was present. Integration of P. punctiformis with cultural and mechanical tools can be an effective way to reduce C. arvense vigor. However, successful integration of the biocontrol can be dependent on a combination of environmental factors and deliberate cropping system management. While P. punctiformis is not a singular management solution, it has potential to be integrated into reduced disturbance cropping systems for long-term and sustainable C. arvense management.