A mess of rotten eggs from the Two Medicine Formation, Montana

Abstract

The Two Medicine Formation of Montana is known for producing many dinosaur eggs in varying states of preservation. An unusual clutch of eggs MOR 11881 was recently found in the formation that exhibits some distinctive preservation features. The purpose of this research is to describe this clutch using multiple techniques to identify and better understand its taphonomic history. To do this the clutch was prepared by removing sediment from around the eggs, then examined using light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), cathodoluminescence (CL), energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy (EDX), and electron backscatter diffraction analysis (EBSD). Preparation uncovered eleven partially compressed ellipsoidal eggs in the clutch. Microscopy of the eggshell revealed that it is made of two structurally distinct layers. The lower layer at the base of the eggshell is here referred to as the blocky layer based on the blocky texture of the crystals in SEM images. This layer is sometimes interrupted by a phosphatic dark region. The second layer is the lobed layer found along the outer surface of the eggshell. It is characterized by lobes of blocky crystals surrounded by smaller radiating crystals. In addition to the eggshell the eggs also preserve a phosphatized eggshell membrane, two distinct types of pellets, large masses of collophane crystals and hyphae like structures. Unaltered eggshell is found in the sediment surrounding the clutch. The eggshell of the MOR 11881 clutch does not match any described ootaxon but is similar to eggshell found at the Egg Mountain quarry which was never identified. The unusual structure of the eggshell could be the result of multiple stages of alteration. Several structures in the eggshell including the lobes and the dark region are most likely the result of alteration. The presence of unaltered eggshell near the eggs indicates that the source of alteration was the decay of the eggs as recorded by their contents. This decay also produced the conditions necessary for the exceptional preservation of the eggshell membrane.